God and the Man at Yale: The Superstition of "Academic Freedom"

USE THE "WORLD'S BEST at NO EXTRA COST Begin your career by doing what the masters do... use CASTELL with the famous imported graphite. It costs no more than ordinary domestic brands. 18 superlative degrees that match every mood of genius. Ask for CASTELL 9000 at your college supply store. 0000 CASTELL ABER AW FABER-CASTELS PENCIL COMPANY INC. NEWARK 4. NU BOOKS GOD AND MAN AT YALE: The Superstitions of "Academic Freedom" by William F. Buckley, Jr. Henry Regnery, Chicago $3.50 Reviewed by Hallett Smith Chairman of the Division of the Humanities VALE IS A UNIVERSITY in New Haven, Connecticut. Among the diverse and distinguished living alumni of the place are Dean Ache-son, Senator Taft, Clark Millikan and Henry R. Luce. The alma ends "For God, for Country and for Yale," and in New Haven this series is not felt to be But a recent graduate, William F. Buckley, Jr., of the Class of 1950, has now fired a broadside at the University for not doing right by God or Country. The faculty is, he composed largely of atheistic socialists, and, what is even more surprising, he claims that the students are strongly influenced by the teaching. This kind of complaint is not new; it has been heard many times in recent years from politicians, super-oatriotic organizations and West brook Pegler. It is unusual, how- ever, to hear the complaint, so elaborately presented as it is in this book, from an able and clever young man just out of the university. Mr. Buckley writes well and knows how to dramatize his points in the manner of a skillful debater. His book deserves, and will get, attention from alumni of privately-controlled insti- vorks against Christianity, is fairl well defined. By Christianity Mr. means a personal faith, something be desertiss and past describes the courses offered in the field, mentioning the professors by name and analyzing their religious positions. Even the courses taught by clergy- cause they are not direct exhortations of the faith. It is a little difhcult to see how anything short of Billy Graham would satisfy him. defend or explain his conception of Christian-ity; he merely says he is committed to it. But he apparently puts little emphasis upon the Christian virtue of humility: God and Man at Yale Mr. Buckley's argument on economics amounts really, as the author frankly admits, to an attack upon academic freedom. He believes that the Yale alumni believers in enterprise, "The American Way, capitalism as it operated in this country before 1932. The social science faculty at Yale does not teach this gospel, he says, and it is the clear duty of the alumni to withhold financial support until it does. have the alumni constitute selves a board of censorship on textbooks and a board of inquisition on faculty members and their beliefs. (This in the name of "individual-ism.") What kind of university Yale would be if Mr. Buckley had his way is somewhat hard to imagine. I do not think it would have many students, and I feel fairly sure it could never again boast of such names as Benjamin Silliman, Josiah Willard Gibbs or William Graham Sumner on its faculty. It would be evangelical and to the right of Sen-tor Taft. But could it possibly b alled a great university? Mr. Buckley's case against Yale is elaborately documented, and his book may well cause alarm among many alumni. I think the total effect of the book can only be described as harmful to higher education and to the university the author says he For this is no thoughtful, examination, despite all the cases cited. It is a slick job of special pleading. When he is confronted with an important statement of a point of view opposed to his, like the great letter of Grenville Clark to a disgruntled alumnus of the Harvarr Law School, he avoids discussing the content of the letter but calls it "a erudite statement" makes a great to-do about the num-of words used by the parties in the controversy. He is very adroit at shifting his ground, and he is in possession of a large arsenal of loaded phrases. He will not expose his own position to attack, but keeps calling up offensive reserves from his recent personal experiences at Yale, the published opinions of people on his side, and, most of all, quotations out of context. Mr. Buckley says he realizes that exaggeration and distortion would do Yale unwarranted damage and cause personal humiliation to him- self. • reviewer can only repor that the exaggeration and distortion. are right there, in the book.